SHOULD INDONESIAN COMISSION BROADCASTING BLOCK PARTICULAR TV SHOW?
In Indonesia, there are lots of television program taken by abroad.
Not only adapting, but also showing television progam from various country. It
carries many advantages but of course disadvantages. For instance, abroad’s
cartoon display in Indonesia. It creates diversity show and sure that it
entertaints people, for children definitely. It causes probably because the
lack of making an exciting cartoon series in Indonesia. Therefore, it is too
boring. So, every television channel, almost of them, national or private
television station, show cartoon series. It becomes an attraction in every
television channel. In contrast, recently the people protest due to Indonesian
Comission Broadcasting (ICB) because they do excessive work. They bluring a lot
of objects in cartoon series that they think it is prohibited in Indonesia. It
reaped much criticism among people. Many think that ICB should not censor
particular part of cartoon’s figure body; however I believe that showing a cartoon
character that wear bikini is inappropriate.
Opponents think that ICB should not be too excessive in censoring.
The statement addressed to recently issue about bluring the cartoon’s figure body.
For instance, the character Sandy in Spongebob Squarepants serial cartoon. She
looks wear bikini, but the particular part of Sandy’s body was being censor. It
caused critisize from people because they think that it was too exaggerated. It
was just an animation, especially it was not excessive. Sandy is a cartoon
figure, they said. Hence, they critisize the policy of ICB. However, ICB has
clarified what has became problem among people. They said that ICB affirmed it
did not issue of any policies or request to broadcast (TV station) to spread
animation program, cartoon and broadcast of Putri Indonesia. ICB also stated
that its institution was not a censorship institution. It conveyed by ICB in
response to the statement of netizens in the social media circulating in recent
times that ICB did so. ICB also never issued a policy or rules outside the
provisions of the broadcasting standard and broadcasting program standard
(P3SPS) ICB 2012. The rules contained in P3SPS has very clear stated what can
and shoud not to be broadcasted such as prohibition of displaying scene of
violence and pornography. ICB regulation is not intended to limit the
creativity of the broadcasters. Broadcasting agency is welcome to pay attention
to every program of the program with a view or aesthetic that is feasible and
worthy to be aired for the public. It means, probably TV station bluring their
TV show in order to avoids reprimands from ICB.
Opponnets also maintain that ICB does not have right in censoring.
Because by censoring it means that ICB limits the creativity of TV station.
However, as a part of Indonesian institution, it has authority based on
constitution number 32-2002 about broadcasting. It stated “set broadcast
program standard, drafting regulation and guideline as well as broadcast
program, standard, sanction violation of regulation and broadcast behaviour
guideline and broadcats program standard, coordinate and/or cooperate with the
government, broadcast and the public. Then, ICB also has the criteria for
setting broadcast standard. Some of them are; tribal, religious, racial and
intergroup values, norms of decency, public service program, privacy right,
protection to children, to certain people and communities, the content of
sexuality, violent content and restriction on cigarette charge and drugs.
\
The final argument stated by opponent of this topic is ICB should
not prohibit any broadcasting by broadcast company in Indonesia. As a TV
channel, they may show any content as long as it is eligible to show in
Indonesia. However, it may be true that the TV show displayed by broadcast
company must eligible in Indonesia, but they must notice the content within it.
It must according to the culture of Indonesia. Western culture (that brings
negative impact) must prohibited in Indonesia. Then, it has to depend on the
customs and religion in Indonesia.
Statement that involve ICB has not any policy in filter TV show is
totally unfounded. The arguments above are evidents to argue the opponents
statement. TV station should provide positive content to build and educate good
character of Indonesian society. Finally, show cartoon programs from other
country is allowed. As long as it is suitable with religion, culture and
customs in Indonesia. Hence, in my opinion, the cartoon figure that wear
incompetible custome must be prohibited.